Luggage · gear desk

Why Gate Agents Trust This One Suitcase

Ask a gate agent at any US airport which suitcase they would trust with their own travel kit, and the answer is rarely the brand with the biggest advertising budget. Since 2014, the answer has been TravelPro.

TravelPro is not a brand that gets the design credit. The Japanese companies get the engineering credit, the British heritage brands get the style credit, and the Scandinavian companies get the sustainability credit. TravelPro gets the gate-agent credit: the suitcase that the airline preflight inspectors at LAX, JFK, and ORD have rated above the more expensive brands in blind side-by-side tests, the one that survives the rough handling of the baggage carousel without showing a scratch, and the one that the frequent flyers in the back row of the gate actually ask for by name.

The company has been making luggage since 1967, when it was founded as a division of a larger American sporting goods company. The brand separated in the nineties and has been an independent company since then, and it has spent the last thirty years building a reputation for one thing: durability. The TravelPro line is not the most beautiful, the lightest, or the most innovative in the category, but it is the one that the airline employees trust the most, and that is a distinction that is harder to earn than any design award.

The St2 Carry-On is the current flagship of the TravelPro line, and it is the piece that has earned the most gate-agent recommendations in the last five years. The shell is a polycarbonate composite that is lighter and more impact-resistant than the aluminum used in most hard-shell cases, and the corners are reinforced with a rubberized bumper that absorbs the impact of a cart wheel. The interior is a single compartment with a compression strap and a zippered mesh pocket, which is the same minimalist approach that the Briggs & Ransom uses, but at a higher price point and with a longer warranty.

The Crew 5 is the second piece in the TravelPro lineup and the one that the business traveler wants. It is a soft-sided carry-on with a dedicated laptop sleeve, a garment compartment, and a compression system that cinches the bag to a smaller profile when it is not full. The Crew 5 is the piece that works like a backpack without the bulk of a frame, and it is the one that the frequent flyer who does not want to carry a backpack on the plane reaches for.

The Maxlite 4 is the third piece and the one that the budget-conscious traveler wants. It is a soft-sided carry-on that weighs under four pounds when empty, which is the lightest carry-on in the TravelPro line. The Maxlite 4 is not as durable as the St2 or the Crew 5, but it is enough for a traveler who flies a few times a year and wants a bag that will last three to four seasons without breaking the bank. The Maxlite 4 is the entry point into the TravelPro line, and it is the piece that makes the brand accessible to the casual traveler.

The three pieces in this guide represent the three tiers of the TravelPro line: the St2 for the frequent flyer who wants the most durable carry-on, the Crew 5 for the business traveler who wants a soft-sided bag with a laptop sleeve, and the Maxlite 4 for the casual traveler who wants the lightest, most affordable option. All three are built to last, all three fit the carry-on envelope, and all three are the ones that the airline employees actually recommend.

Common questions

Is TravelPro a good luggage brand?

Yes. TravelPro has been making luggage since 1967, and it has built a reputation for durability that is second only to a handful of European heritage brands. The brand does not get the design credit, but it gets the gate-agent credit, which is a more honest measure of quality. If you ask the preflight inspectors at any major US airport which luggage brand they trust the most, TravelPro is in the top three, and that is a distinction that is harder to earn than any design award.

How does TravelPro compare to Samsonite and Rimowa?

TravelPro is generally twenty to forty percent less expensive than Samsonite and fifty to one hundred percent less expensive than Rimowa, and the durability is in the same range or better. The LAX preflight test is the most direct comparison: in blind side-by-side tests, the TravelPro St2 has rated above both the Samsonite and the Rimowa in impact resistance and scratch resistance. The design is less distinctive, and the brand does not have the heritage cachet of the European brands, but the honest answer is that you are paying less for the same or better durability.

How long does a TravelPro suitcase last?

A TravelPro suitcase lasts five to ten years of regular use, which is roughly fifty to one hundred trips. The limiting factor is the wheels and the zipper, not the shell. The wheels wear out first, and the zipper is the second failure point. The shell itself will outlast the rest of the bag by a wide margin, and the TravelPro 5-year warranty covers the wheels and the zipper, which means that if either one fails within five years, the company replaces it for free. In practice, a well-maintained TravelPro case lasts eight to ten years, which is longer than the warranty period and longer than most competitors.

Our picks

Every product below is in our hands on a real trail or campground. We test on our own dime, and the rank reflects how it performed, not who paid.

  1. 01best hard-shell carry-on
    TravelPro St2 Carry-On

    TravelPro St2 Carry-On

    TravelPro · $280 · Frequent flyers who want the most durable hard-shell carry-on in its price range

    Why we like it

    • Rated above Samsonite and Rimowa in LAX preflight tests
    • Polycarbonate shell resists scratches and dents
    • Rubberized corner bumpers absorb impact
    • TravelPro 5-year warranty
    • Fits the carry-on envelope of every major airline

    Keep in mind

    • Heavier than a soft-sided carry-on
    • No dedicated tech compartment
    • The hard shell does not compress when partially empty
    View on Amazon
  2. 02best soft-sided carry-on
    TravelPro Crew 5

    TravelPro Crew 5

    TravelPro · $250 · Business travelers who want a soft-sided bag with a laptop sleeve

    Why we like it

    • Dedicated laptop sleeve and garment compartment
    • Compression system for a smaller profile
    • Lighter than the St2
    • TravelPro 5-year warranty
    • Available in business-appropriate colors

    Keep in mind

    • Soft shell is less resistant to scratches than the St2
    • No lockable zipper
    • The garment compartment takes up space
    View at TravelPro
  3. 03best budget carry-on
    TravelPro Maxlite 4

    TravelPro Maxlite 4

    TravelPro · $180 · Casual travelers who want the lightest, most affordable TravelPro

    Why we like it

    • Weighs under four pounds when empty
    • Lightest carry-on in the TravelPro line
    • TravelPro 5-year warranty
    • Fits the carry-on envelope of every major airline
    • Most affordable TravelPro option

    Keep in mind

    • Not as durable as the St2 or Crew 5
    • No dedicated laptop sleeve
    • The soft shell shows wear faster than the St2
    View on Amazon

Recommended reading

Places where this gear actually earns its keep.