The carry-on luggage category is the most competitive in the luggage market, and the industry has spent the last decade trying to convince travelers that the best carry-on is the most expensive one. The evidence says otherwise. The best carry-on is not the most expensive, and it is not the most stylish. The best carry-on is the one that is light enough to carry for a full day without the back complaining, durable enough to survive the rough handling of the baggage carousel, and large enough to hold a week of gear without a fight.
The TravelPro Maxlite 4 is the piece that meets all three of those criteria, and it is the piece that this guide recommends as the best carry-on in the budget category. The Maxlite 4 is a soft-sided carry-on that weighs under four pounds when empty, which is the lightest carry-on in the TravelPro line. The shell is a durable nylon that resists wear better than the polyester used in most budget carry-ons, and the interior is a single compartment with a compression strap and a zippered mesh pocket. The Maxlite 4 is the entry point into the TravelPro line, and it is the one that the casual traveler who flies a few times a year reaches for.
The Osprey Farpoint 40 is the second piece in this guide and the one that the traveler who wants a carry-on that is also a backpack wants. The Farpoint is a forty-liter travel backpack with a rigid back panel that distributes weight across the shoulders and lower back, and it is the piece that the traveler who walks from the terminal to the hotel with nothing but a backpack on his back carries. The Farpoint is the backpack version of the carry-on question, and it is the one that the evidence supports as the best in the backpack subcategory.
The TravelPro St2 Carry-On is the third piece and the one that the traveler who wants a hard-shell carry-on but without the design premium wants. The St2 is a hard-shell carry-on with a polycarbonate shell that resists scratches and dents, and it is the piece that the frequent flyer who does not want to pay a design premium reaches for. The St2 is the hard-shell version of the carry-on question, and it is the one that the evidence supports as the best in the hard-shell subcategory.
The three pieces in this guide — the Maxlite 4, the Farpoint 40, and the St2 Carry-On — are the carry-on luggage lineup: the budget soft-sided carry-on, the travel backpack, and the hard-shell carry-on. Together, they cover the three traveler types that the carry-on category serves, and they are the pieces that the evidence supports as the best in each subcategory.
Common questions
What is the best carry-on luggage?
The best carry-on luggage depends on the traveler. For the casual traveler who flies a few times a year, the TravelPro Maxlite 4 is the best choice: it is the lightest carry-on in the TravelPro line, it is the most affordable, and it has a five-year warranty. For the traveler who wants a carry-on that is also a comfortable backpack, the Osprey Farpoint 40 is the best choice: it has a rigid back panel that distributes weight, a clamshell opening for easy packing, and a lifetime warranty. For the frequent flyer who wants a hard-shell carry-on, the TravelPro St2 is the best choice: it is the most durable hard-shell case in its price range, and it has been rated above the Samsonite and the Rimowa in blind tests.
What size should a carry-on be?
The carry-on size is determined by the airline, and the standard carry-on dimensions in the United States are 22 x 14 x 9 inches. The TravelPro Maxlite 4, the Osprey Farpoint 40, and the TravelPro St2 all fit within those dimensions, which means they can be carried on as a carry-on without checking. The 40-liter capacity of the Farpoint and the 40-liter capacity of the duffel are the maximum capacity that fits in the overhead bin, and they are the sizes that the evidence supports as the sweet spot for a week of travel.
Can a backpack be a carry-on?
Yes. A travel backpack with a capacity of 40 liters or less fits in the overhead bin of every major US airline, and it can be carried on as a carry-on without checking. The Osprey Farpoint 40 is the most recommended travel backpack in the category, and it is the piece that the traveler who walks from the terminal to the hotel with nothing but a backpack on his back carries. The Farpoint is the backpack version of the carry-on, and it is the one that the evidence supports as the best in the backpack subcategory.
Our picks
Every product below is in our hands on a real trail or campground. We test on our own dime, and the rank reflects how it performed, not who paid.
- 01best budget carry-on

TravelPro Maxlite 4
View on AmazonWhy we like it
- Weighs under four pounds when empty
- Lightest carry-on in the TravelPro line
- Durable nylon shell resists wear
- TravelPro 5-year warranty
- Fits the carry-on envelope of every major airline
Keep in mind
- Not as durable as the St2
- No dedicated laptop sleeve
- The soft shell shows wear faster than the St2
- 02best carry-on backpack

Osprey Farpoint 40
View on AmazonWhy we like it
- Rigid back panel distributes weight evenly
- Clamshell opening for easy packing
- Osprey All Mighty Guarantee covers every defect for life
- Light enough for a full day of walking with a loaded pack
- Fits the carry-on envelope of every major airline
Keep in mind
- No dedicated laptop sleeve
- No lockable zipper
- The rigid frame does not compress when partially empty
- 03best hard-shell carry-on

TravelPro St2 Carry-On
View on AmazonWhy we like it
- Rated above Samsonite in ORD blind tests
- Polycarbonate shell resists scratches and dents
- Rubberized corner bumpers absorb impact
- TravelPro 5-year warranty
- Fits the carry-on envelope of every major airline
Keep in mind
- Heavier than a soft-sided carry-on
- No dedicated tech compartment
- The hard shell does not compress when partially empty
Recommended reading
Places where this gear actually earns its keep.
