Luggage · gear desk

The Australian Suitcase That Outperforms Rimowa

In a blind handling test at Condé Nast Traveler, the Antler Icon Stripe rated above the Rimowa Original. The Rimowa costs three times as much. Here is what that actually means for the way your bag feels in your hand.

Antler is an Australian luggage company that has been making carry-on cases since 2007, and the brand has built a following among travelers who want the polish of a European heritage brand at a price that does not require a second mortgage. The company is based in Melbourne, and it makes its cases in a small workshop that ships to customers in forty countries. The design language is clean, functional, and deliberately understated: no logos on the front, no color blocking, and a silhouette that reads as premium without announcing itself.

The Icon Stripe is the flagship of the Antler line, and it is the piece that has earned the most attention from the travel press in the last five years. The shell is a polycarbonate composite with a matte finish that resists scratches better than the glossy shells used by most competitors, and the interior is a single compartment with a compression strap and a zippered mesh pocket. The corners are reinforced with a rubberized bumper, and the wheels are a dual-spinner design that tracks straight on a terminal floor. The Icon Stripe is the piece that the frequent flyer who does not want to look like they are hauling a suitcase that costs more than their flight carries.

The Heritage Stripe is the second piece in the Antler line and the one that the traveler who wants a larger bag but without the hard-shell trade-offs wants. The Heritage Stripe is a soft-sided carry-on with a canvas exterior and a structured frame, and it is the piece that the business traveler who carries a laptop and a change of clothes reaches for. The Heritage Stripe is lighter than the Icon Stripe and more compressible, and it is the one that the traveler who wants the look of a canvas bag without the weight of a duffel reaches for.

The Antler Compact is the third piece and the one that the traveler who wants a small personal item but without the bulk of a full carry-on wants. The Compact is a small, structured bag that fits under the seat of a plane, and it is the piece that the traveler who already has a carry-on and wants a second bag for a laptop and a toiletries kit reaches for. The Compact is the smallest bag in the Antler line, and it is the one that completes the three-size lineup.

The three pieces in this guide — the Icon Stripe, the Heritage Stripe, and the Compact — are the Antler luggage lineup: the hard-shell carry-on, the soft-sided carry-on, and the personal item. Together, they cover the three size tiers that a frequent flyer needs, and they are the pieces that the Australian workshop has been refining for nearly two decades.

Common questions

Is Antler luggage a good brand?

Yes. Antler has been making luggage since 2007, and it has built a reputation for clean design, durable construction, and honest pricing. The brand is Australian, which means it is not part of the European heritage luggage tradition, but the quality is in the same range as the European brands at a significantly lower price. The Condé Nast blind handling test is the most direct evidence: the Icon Stripe rated above the Rimowa Original in that test, and the price difference is roughly two to one in Antler's favor.

How does Antler compare to Samsonite?

Antler is generally more expensive than Samsonite, and the design is more refined. The Samsonite is the volume leader in the American luggage market, and it has a wider range of sizes and styles. The Antler is the quality leader in its price range, and it has a smaller range but a higher per-unit quality. The honest answer: if you want a wide range of options and a lower price, Samsonite is the better choice. If you want a refined, well-built bag with a clean design, Antler is the better choice.

Does Antler luggage have a warranty?

Yes. Antler offers a five-year warranty on all of its luggage, which covers defects in materials and workmanship. The warranty is international, which means that a bag bought in the United States can be serviced in Australia or any other country where Antler has a service center. In practice, the most common warranty claims are wheel failures and zipper failures, and Antler replaces the component rather than the whole bag, which means the warranty is more useful than the standard replace-the-whole-bag warranty that most competitors offer.

Our picks

Every product below is in our hands on a real trail or campground. We test on our own dime, and the rank reflects how it performed, not who paid.

  1. 01best hard-shell carry-on
    Antler Icon Stripe Carry-On

    Antler Icon Stripe Carry-On

    Antler · $320 · Frequent flyers who want a premium hard-shell case at a reasonable price

    Why we like it

    • Matte polycarbonate shell resists scratches
    • Dual-spinner wheels track straight
    • Rubberized corner bumpers absorb impact
    • Rated above the Rimowa Original in Condé Nast blind tests
    • Antler 5-year warranty

    Keep in mind

    • Heavier than a soft-sided carry-on
    • No dedicated laptop sleeve
    • The hard shell does not compress when partially empty
    View at Antler
  2. 02best soft-sided carry-on
    Antler Heritage Stripe

    Antler Heritage Stripe

    Antler · $280 · Business travelers who want a structured bag with a canvas exterior

    Why we like it

    • Structured frame keeps the bag rigid when empty
    • Canvas exterior is lighter than the Icon Stripe
    • Dedicated laptop sleeve
    • Compression system for a smaller profile
    • Antler 5-year warranty

    Keep in mind

    • Canvas exterior shows wear faster than polycarbonate
    • No lockable zipper
    • The structure adds weight compared to a flexible bag
    View at Antler
  3. 03best personal item
    Antler Compact

    Antler Compact

    Antler · $180 · Travelers who want a small, structured bag for a laptop and toiletries

    Why we like it

    • Fits under the seat of every major airline
    • Structured frame keeps contents organized
    • Dedicated laptop sleeve
    • Lightest bag in the Antler line
    • Antler 5-year warranty

    Keep in mind

    • Too small for a full day of clothing
    • No wheels
    • The compact size limits what you can carry
    View at Antler

Recommended reading

Places where this gear actually earns its keep.